Is Metallica Having Money Problems?
Considering that Metallica has sold more albums than most other metal acts and that they continue to be a highly desirable live draw, it’s hard to believe that the band may be struggling financially. But, UK authors Paul Brannigan and Ian Winwood believe that the Master of Puppets makers have been losing money since 2010.
While promoting their book Into the Black: The Inside Story of Metallica 1991-2014 during an interview with The Weeklings, the duo were asked about their published theory that “Since 2010 it’s likely that Metallica have lost more money than they’ve made.”
To which the duo replied: “Well, over the past five years Metallica have embarked upon a variety of vanity projects that haven’t exactly brought home the bacon. By their own admission, the two stagings of the Orion festival were disastrous financially, and the shambles that was the Through The Never movie cost $32 million and will only recoup a fraction of that amount. Factor in HQ staff salaries, crew retainers and assorted running costs associated with maintaining an entertainment corporation and you can easily understand why the band – of necessity now rather than by choice – are driven to tour Europe every summer. No one is going to shed any tears upon hearing Metallica pleading poverty, but over the past decade their margins will undoubtedly have taken a hammering.”
When the authors were asked what they consider to be the biggest blunder Metallica has recently made, the pair had trouble selecting just one instance.
“There’s a line from ‘Damage Inc.’ on Master of Puppets which runs ‘Honesty is my only excuse…’, and many of what outsiders might regard as Metallica’s missteps, if not outright mistakes – from Lars Ulrich’s bullish campaign against Napster through to Lulu and Through The Never – have stemmed from their own bloody-mindedness. It’s hard to fault a band that (largely) operates on such principles however, so I’d be loath to label these decisions as ‘blunders’. When Metallica mistrust their own instincts however, they falter, and increasingly in recent years that’s made them look at best infallible and at worst dishonest. The whole Through The Never film project was a horrible misjudgment, a misguided attempt to breathe new life into a decade-old idea. As the film spiraled horribly over-budget it’s hard not to imagine that at least one band member – and let’s be honest, we’re talking about James Hetfield here – thinking ‘What the fuck have we got ourselves into?’ Quite how that ‘script’ ever got the green light is an unfathomable mystery.”
Metallica is currently at work on their first album since 2008’s Death Magnetic.